The Energy Consumer's Bulletin- a New England energy news blog

  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

New Proposed Changes To Demand Response In Rhode Island

Rhode Island Energy (RIE), the Ocean State's electric utility company, has proposed changes to its demand response program known as ConnectedSolutions. RIE has presented its proposed changes to the program to RI's Energy Efficiency Council (EEC), and the Council is expected to vote on the approval of this plan during its November 19 meeting. This blog will provide context on how ConnectedSolutions and demand response work, what is in the proposal the RIE has put forth, and what we would like to see changed in the proposal before it is approved.

Submit comments here to the EEC regarding RIE’s ConnectedSolutions proposal by November 19 to help create the strongest possible demand response program for Rhode Island.

 

What is Demand Response?

During the summer, there are a handful of days where electric usage becomes very high and creates stress on the power grid. These instances typically occur during the hottest days of the year when everyone turns on their ACs for cooling at the same time, creating what is known as "peak demand" on the grid. Peak demand days cause electric utilities to turn to oil-fired “peaker” power plants to meet the increased electric demand, which are the most expensive and polluting sources of power generation available.

The idea behind demand response is to let people know when peak demand days are occurring so that they can change their electricity usage patterns. This reduces demand for electricity during constrained hours and in turn eliminates the need to use expensive and polluting peaker plants. By reducing peak demand, we can also avoid the need to build more transmission and distribution infrastructure, which is expensive and ultimately falls on ratepayers.

There are many different types of demand response programs that people can participate in. We at Green Energy Consumers have run our "Shave the Peak" demand response program for over a decade now, which provides conservation alerts letting you know when a peak demand day is occurring so that you can lower your electricity usage on a volunteer basis to help bring down peak demand. You can learn more about Shave the Peak and lessons we learned from this past summer here.

Electric utility companies also run their own demand response programs, most of which offer incentives to participate. The idea is: it’s cheaper for society as a whole to incentivize people to reduce their electric load during peak hours than it is to use those disproportionately expensive peaker plants. Several states in New England have a utility-run demand response program known as ConnectedSolutions, including Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and New Hampshire. For residential customers, there are several pathways through which you can participate and receive incentives, depending on the technology you choose to enroll.

  • Smart thermostats: You enable your utility to pre-cool and then slightly adjust your thermostat up for a couple of hours during the peak demand period.
  • Battery storage system (commonly paired with solar panels or used as standalone backup power): You enable your utility to discharge the power from your battery either to your home or the grid.

Both participation pathways come with compensation, and the level of compensation you receive will vary based on the utility that is administering the program.

smart thermostat - blog image-1

 

What's in Rhode Island Energy’s Proposal?

ConnectedSolutions has been operating in Rhode Island since 2019 and operates on a three-year planning cycle. The current proposal for changes being made to RIE's ConnectedSolutions program is for the upcoming three-year period from 2027 to 2029. The proposal makes some tweaks to some of the existing pathways for participation, as well as introducing a new pathway and making changes to how incentive rates are set.

Here is a summary of what is being proposed for the upcoming ConnectedSolutions term:

  • The smart thermostat pathway currently includes a $50 one-time enrollment bonus and a yearly $20 participation incentive.
    • RIE proposes to only provide the yearly incentive to customers who participate in at least one event per year (previously, you could receive it even if you opted out of all events).
  • The electric vehicle demand response pathway includes curtailing your EV charging during peak electric demand hours and has the same compensation structure as the smart thermostat pathway.
    • RIE proposes to only provide the yearly incentive to customers who participate in at least one event per year.
  • The residential battery pathway provides $225 per kilowatt (kW) for the average contribution of your battery.
    • RIE proposes decreasing the incentive to $200/kW, as well as decreasing the guarantee of that incentive rate from five years to three years.
  • RIE has also proposed a new pathway called Background Energy Adjustments, through which you can enroll your smart thermostat through your device’s manufacturer. RIE will then make small adjustments to the temperature; however, there is no compensation for this pathway.
  • For commercial and industrial sector customers, RIE has proposed to decrease the participation incentive from $275/kW of average demand reduction to $200/kW. RIE is also proposing to implement a performance factor, which means that the actual incentive received will depend on the frequency of participation, not just the average demand reduction.

home battery blog image

 

Our Thoughts on the Proposal

We believe that demand response programs such as ConnectedSolutions are vital to facilitating peak demand reduction, which can help reduce system-wide costs to all customers as well as decrease emissions through reduced reliance on polluting peaker plants. Continuing to support ConnectedSolutions is crucial to achieving Rhode Island's broader climate goals in the state’s Climate Action Strategy as well as in the Act On Climate. While there are aspects of the current proposal that we support, such as the changes to the smart thermostat and EV demand response category, there are aspects of the proposal we would like to see explained in greater detail or altered in order for ConnectedSolutions to deliver the most savings to ratepayers.

Justification for Incentive Decreases

RIE proposed decreasing their incentive amounts for the residential battery pathway, which has the highest average load reduction out of all the devices that are eligible to participate. We would like to see more evidence behind why a decrease in the incentive level is warranted. RIE stated that the decision to reduce compensation was made considering the existence of other complementary incentives offered by the Office of Energy Resources and financial support through the HEAT loan. We believe that customers should be fairly compensated for the value their devices are providing to the grid, and that the existence of other rebates or financing mechanisms does not change the material impact that a customer is having on the grid by participating in ConnectedSolutions.

ConnectedSolutions in Rhode Island also has the lowest incentive level for battery storage participation across similar programs across New England. Since ConnectedSolutions is designed to address system-level constraints, which account for the entirety of the regional grid in New England, we would like to see more explanation given as to why there is such a wide discrepancy in incentive levels across the states even though all the programs are designed to address the same peak demand days.

State Incentive (Residential Battery Pathway)
Massachusetts $275/kW
Connecticut $300/kW
Rhode Island (current) $225/kW
Rhode Island (proposed) $200/kW

Background Energy Adjustments Pathway is a Distraction

We believe that the new pathway for participation that has been introduced, known as Background Energy Adjustments, will only serve to confuse customers who have a smart thermostat and want to participate in ConnectedSolutions. The new pathway would require customers to enroll their smart thermostat through their device's manufacturer instead of with RIE directly, and the customer would receive no compensation for participating. We think that this would be confusing to customers, especially considering there is already a pathway to participate that offers an incentive to enroll your smart thermostat. More attention should be given to improving the existing smart thermostat pathway instead of creating a competing pathway that does not compensate customers for their contributions to the grid.

Rate-Locks Should Remain Stable

Historically, when a customer enrolled their battery with ConnectedSolutions, they were given a five-year guarantee that their incentive level would not change. Now, RIE has proposed moving away from this five-year rate lock towards what they call a Multi-Year Rate, which is only guaranteed for three years. Residential battery systems can be a significant investment to take on, so it is important for customers to be able to count on their incentive payments remaining stable. If incentive levels are volatile and change with every new ConnectedSolutions proposal, it may discourage prospective participants in the program from investing in battery storage due to the high upfront cost.

 

What Next?

RIE has recently presented its proposal for the upcoming term of the ConnectedSolutions program to the EEC. The Council will vote to approve this plan at its next meeting, which is scheduled for November 19, 2026. If the plan is approved by the Council, RIE will then file the proposal with the Public Utilities Commission, where it will be deliberated further before final approval. We wrote a letter to EEC expressing some of the concerns that we discussed above.

The EEC provides the opportunity for members of the public to submit comments ahead of their meetings, so if you have any thoughts about the ConnectedSolutions Proposal, you can submit them here before the November 19 deadline. Here is a drafted comment you can submit to the EEC:

Dear Members of the Energy Efficiency Council,

I am providing this comment to urge the Council to require that Rhode Island Energy put forth the strongest possible proposal for demand response through their ConnectedSolutions Program.

Continuing to support ConnectedSolutions is crucial to achieving Rhode Island's climate goals in the state’s Climate Action Strategy as well as in the Act on Climate. The EEC should seek additional elaboration from RIE on (1) the rationale for setting incentive levels and rate locks at the levels that have been proposed and (2) the role that incentivizing battery adoption plays in increasing the success of ConnectedSolutions as a whole.

I appreciate the opportunity to provide this comment to the EEC.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]

Comments